GPS vs. Smartphone Navigation for Your Car Rental: Which is Better?
When planning a road trip in Australia with a rental car, one of the first things you'll need to consider is navigation. Should you rely on a dedicated GPS device, or is your smartphone with its navigation apps sufficient? Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences. This article will compare GPS devices and smartphone navigation across key criteria to help you make an informed decision.
1. Accuracy and Reliability
Accuracy and reliability are paramount when you're relying on a navigation system to get you to your destination safely and efficiently. Let's examine how GPS devices and smartphones stack up in these areas.
GPS Devices
Pros: Dedicated GPS devices are designed solely for navigation. They typically have a strong GPS signal and are less prone to interference from other apps or processes running in the background. Many GPS devices also come with pre-loaded maps, which means they can function even in areas with no mobile network coverage. This is a significant advantage in remote parts of Australia where mobile signal can be patchy or non-existent.
Cons: Map updates can be infrequent and costly. Outdated maps can lead to inaccurate directions and missed turns. While they are generally reliable, GPS devices can sometimes experience glitches or software issues.
Smartphone Navigation
Pros: Smartphone navigation apps like Google Maps and Apple Maps benefit from frequent map updates, often several times a month. This ensures you have access to the latest road information, including new roads, updated speed limits, and real-time traffic conditions. The accuracy of smartphone GPS has improved significantly over the years, and they generally perform well in urban areas.
Cons: Smartphones rely on a mobile data connection to download map data and receive real-time traffic updates. In areas with poor or no mobile coverage, navigation may be limited or unavailable. GPS accuracy can also be affected by tall buildings, tunnels, and other obstructions. Furthermore, the accuracy of crowd-sourced data, which some apps use, can sometimes be questionable. It's worth checking frequently asked questions about connectivity before you leave.
2. Ease of Use and Interface
The user interface and overall ease of use are important factors to consider, especially if you're not particularly tech-savvy.
GPS Devices
Pros: GPS devices typically have a simple and intuitive interface, designed specifically for navigation. The large screen and clear voice prompts make it easy to follow directions while driving. Many GPS devices also offer features like lane guidance and junction view, which can be helpful in complex intersections.
Cons: The interface can sometimes feel outdated compared to modern smartphone apps. Entering addresses can be cumbersome, especially if you're using a touchscreen keyboard. Searching for points of interest may also be less intuitive than on a smartphone.
Smartphone Navigation
Pros: Smartphone navigation apps have a modern and user-friendly interface. Entering addresses is easy, thanks to the smartphone's keyboard and predictive text features. Searching for points of interest is also simple, using voice search or typing keywords. Many apps also offer features like offline maps, which allow you to download map data for specific areas and use it without a data connection.
Cons: The smaller screen size can make it difficult to view the map and directions while driving. Glare from the sun can also make the screen hard to read. Some users may find the constant notifications and alerts from other apps distracting.
3. Data Usage and Connectivity
Data usage and connectivity are crucial considerations, especially if you're travelling in areas with limited or expensive mobile data.
GPS Devices
Pros: GPS devices don't require a mobile data connection to function, as they rely on satellite signals for navigation. This makes them ideal for use in remote areas with no mobile coverage, or for travellers who want to avoid data roaming charges. As mentioned, many come with pre-loaded maps, eliminating the need for any data usage at all.
Cons: Map updates may require a computer and internet connection. Real-time traffic updates are typically not available without a connected service (often paid).
Smartphone Navigation
Pros: Smartphone navigation apps offer real-time traffic updates, which can help you avoid congestion and save time. They also provide access to a wealth of information, such as reviews of local businesses and opening hours. Some apps offer offline map functionality, allowing you to download maps for specific areas and use them without a data connection. This is especially important in Australia, where mobile data can be expensive and unreliable in some areas. Consider what Carental offers in terms of in-car connectivity.
Cons: Smartphone navigation apps consume mobile data, which can be expensive if you're travelling in Australia and don't have a local SIM card. Data usage can also drain your phone's battery quickly. Relying solely on mobile data can be risky in areas with poor or no mobile coverage. Consider a local SIM card or a portable Wi-Fi hotspot if you plan to use smartphone navigation extensively.
4. Cost and Availability
The cost and availability of GPS devices and smartphone navigation are important factors to consider when making your decision.
GPS Devices
Pros: GPS devices are a one-time purchase, so you don't have to worry about ongoing subscription fees. They are readily available from electronics stores and online retailers. Many car rental companies also offer GPS devices as an optional extra.
Cons: The initial cost of a GPS device can be significant, especially if you want a high-end model with advanced features. Map updates can also be expensive. If you only need navigation for occasional trips, a GPS device may not be the most cost-effective option.
Smartphone Navigation
Pros: Smartphone navigation apps are often free to download and use. Even paid apps are typically much cheaper than a dedicated GPS device. If you already own a smartphone, you don't need to purchase any additional hardware. Many car rental companies offer smartphone mounts, making it easy to use your phone for navigation while driving. You can learn more about Carental and our rental options.
Cons: Using smartphone navigation can incur data charges, especially if you don't have a local SIM card. You may also need to purchase a car mount and a charging cable. Some apps offer premium features that require a subscription fee.
5. Battery Life Considerations
Battery life is a critical factor to consider, especially on long road trips.
GPS Devices
Pros: GPS devices typically have a longer battery life than smartphones, as they are designed specifically for navigation and don't have other apps running in the background. They also come with a car charger, allowing you to keep the device powered up while driving.
Cons: The battery life of a GPS device can still be limited, especially if you're using it for extended periods. It's important to ensure the device is fully charged before setting off on a long journey.
Smartphone Navigation
Pros: Smartphones can be charged while driving using a car charger. Power banks can also be used to extend battery life.
Cons: Smartphone navigation apps can drain your phone's battery quickly, especially if you're using data-intensive features like real-time traffic updates. The screen brightness and other apps running in the background can also impact battery life. It's essential to have a reliable car charger and consider bringing a power bank for emergencies. Consider turning off unnecessary features like Bluetooth and Wi-Fi to conserve battery life.
6. Overall Recommendation
So, which is better: a dedicated GPS device or smartphone navigation? The answer depends on your individual needs and priorities.
Choose a GPS device if: You're travelling to remote areas with limited or no mobile coverage. You want a simple and reliable navigation system with a large screen. You prefer not to use mobile data for navigation. You value longer battery life.
Choose smartphone navigation if: You're travelling in urban areas with good mobile coverage. You want access to real-time traffic updates and other information. You prefer a modern and user-friendly interface. You're comfortable using mobile data for navigation. You already own a smartphone and don't want to purchase additional hardware.
Ultimately, the best approach may be to combine both options. Use your smartphone for navigation in urban areas, and a dedicated GPS device for remote areas or as a backup. This will ensure you always have a reliable navigation system, regardless of your location or mobile coverage. Before you rent a car, check our services to see what options we have available to suit your needs.